Five Questions About Mormon History That Sent Me Back to the Sources
Ask when the Latter-day Saints stopped practicing plural marriage and you’ll probably hear one year: 1890. Then there’s the wedding on the boat. A ledger kept by Church scribes records 25 plural marriages performed after the 1890 Manifesto. Eighteen took place in Mexico, six in the United States, and one aboard a boat on the Pacific Ocean. That last entry makes me wonder about the people on deck that day and what they understood the Manifesto to mean.
That’s the kind of detail that got me working on five websites about Mormon history and doctrine. Each starts with a question I wanted to spend some time with. Sometimes there’s a handwritten page you can read for yourself. Sometimes two Church presidents addressed the same subject more than a century apart and said strikingly different things. Here’s where I’d start.
Did polygamy end in 1890?
Wilford Woodruff’s Manifesto left plural families with an immediate question. What were husbands, wives, and children who had already made covenants to one another supposed to do? Some families separated. Others stayed together and had more children. Then there were the people in that ledger who entered new plural marriages. In 1904, President Joseph F. Smith issued a second Manifesto making both entering and performing a new plural marriage grounds for excommunication. Those fourteen years deserve more than a footnote.
What did John Taylor write in 1886?
Four years before Woodruff issued the Manifesto, President John Taylor wrote down a revelation dated September 27, 1886. It opens with a question about how far the new and everlasting covenant binds the Saints. Near the end comes a phrase that matters enormously to the debate over plural marriage: “the works of Abraham.” If you’ve encountered the story through Ogden Kraut or through later accounts of who received authority to continue plural marriage, try reading Taylor’s handwritten page first. What would you understand those words to require if that page were all you had?
What did Brigham Young teach about Adam?
In an April 1852 sermon, Brigham Young spoke about Adam arriving in Eden and called him “our Father and our God.” In October 1976, Spencer W. Kimball addressed the Adam-God theory in general conference and said, “We denounce that theory.” I’d put those two addresses side by side. Read the paragraphs around Young’s words, then read Kimball’s counsel to Church teachers. You can see both why early Saints took Young’s words seriously and why a Latter-day Saint hearing the idea today might be surprised by them.
Was God once a man?
At the April 1844 conference in Nauvoo, Joseph Smith spoke to people mourning a man named King Follett. In answering a question about death, he also addressed God’s past and what human beings might become. Four listeners took notes. Their accounts give us a chance to read how people in the crowd heard the sermon that day. Lorenzo Snow later put the idea into two memorable lines. The Church’s essay Becoming Like God makes an observation worth pausing over: Latter-day Saints teach a great deal about becoming like Heavenly Father and comparatively little about what Heavenly Father once experienced.
Was Jesus married?
Start with the wedding at Cana in John 2. Jesus and his disciples are invited. His mother notices that the wine has run out. Later, the man overseeing the feast calls for the bridegroom, whose name John leaves out. In 1854, Apostle Orson Hyde preached a sermon identifying Jesus himself as that bridegroom. What interests me is how Hyde got there. With the chapter open beside the sermon, you can follow his argument and decide how much weight it carries.
If you only have time for one, I’d start with the question you think you already know the answer to. And if there’s a sermon, diary entry, or family letter you think I ought to read, I’d genuinely like to hear about it. A name, a date, or a page number gives me somewhere to start.